Skip to main content
California Department of Education Logo

California Fresh Start Program (CFSP) Eval. Report

Executive Summary of findings from the comprehensive evaluation of the pilot implementation of the CFSP mandated by SB 281, and CFSP Evaluation Report.

Executive Summary | CFSP Evaluation Report

Executive Summary

In 2005, California enacted Senate Bill 281, which established the California Fresh Start Program (CFSP), to encourage and support schools to provide additional portions of fresh fruit and vegetables in the School Breakfast Program (SBP). The CFSP, the nation’s first program earmarking funds to increase consumption of fresh fruit and vegetables in a school nutrition program, reimbursed participating schools 10 cents for every breakfast offering an additional serving of fruit and vegetables. In 2006-07, the University of California Berkeley’s Center for Weight and Health conducted an extensive evaluation of the implementation of the CFSP in 69 diverse schools. The findings of the evaluation are detailed in this report.

The CFSP exceeded expectations in many areas. During the CFSP at participating schools:

  • The amount of fresh fruits and vegetables offered to students doubled.
  • The amount of fresh fruit taken by students at breakfast increased to an even greater degree (up 136 percent).
  • The variety of fruits and vegetables offered to students at breakfast increased substantially.
  • The amount of fruit juice schools offered and students took at breakfast decreased.
  • Participation in school breakfast increased by about two percent, enough to bring nearly $1 million in additional federal meal reimbursement to the state.

While the greatest absolute increase in fruit and vegetables provided included the more common fruits—apples, oranges, and bananas—even more significant were the relative increases in more “exotic” fruits, like stone fruits (peaches, apricots, plums etc.), kiwi, pineapple, pears, and tangerines among others.

In addition, the findings indicated that increasing the CFSP reimbursement rate to greater than 10 cents would be necessary to adequately cover the costs of:

  • Fruits and vegetables including losses due to perishability
  • Nutrition education and promotion
  • Labor associated with preparation of produce

During the first year of implementation, the CFSP generated significant increases in the amount of fruits and vegetables offered and taken by students. With the enhancements suggested in the report and expansion to more schools, the CFSP showed potential for still greater success if continued in the future.

CFSP Evaluation Report

The full California Fresh Start Program (CFSP) Evaluation Report External link opens in new window or tab. (PDF) is available on the Center for Weight and Health at the University of California, Berkeley Web site. It is a report of the findings from a comprehensive evaluation of the implementation of the CFSP.

The Center for Weight and Health at the University of California, Berkeley was employed as the independent evaluator by the Alameda County Office of Education External link opens in new window or tab. , recipient of the grant authorized by SB 281 with funds administered by the California Department of Education (CDE).

Questions:   Nutrition Services Division | 800-952-5609
Last Reviewed: Tuesday, March 29, 2016
Recently Posted in Nutrition
  • Prior Approval for CACFP Allowable Costs (added 27-Feb-2017)
    Management Bulletin CACFP-03-2017: Prior Approval for Child and Adult Care Food Program Allowable Costs.
  • CNIPS Training Registration (added 14-Feb-2017)
    Information about CDE-sponsored courses, training locations, and registrations are available on the CNIPS Training Registration Web page. This Web page is accessed from the CNIPS Home Page by selecting the Training Registration link.
  • Food Service Management Company Rebids 2017-18 (added 14-Feb-2017)
    School Food Authorities required to rebid Food Service Management Company contracts for School Year 2017-18.
  • Two-cent Differential Reimbursement for New SFAs (added 30-Jan-2017)
    MB SNP-04-2017, USDA Policy Memo SP 30-2014: Determining Eligibility for Two-cent Differential Reimbursement and SP 23-2005: Eligibility for Severe Need Rates for the School Breakfast Program.
  • Health and Safety Permit and Fire Inspection (added 24-Jan-2017)
    Management Bulletin CACFP-07-2016: Health and Safety Permit and Fire Inspection Requirements for License-exempt Centers.

  • Eligibility Requirements for Military Families (added 19-Jan-2017)
    Management Bulletin CNP-02-2017, USDA Policy Memo SP 06-2010, CACFP 03-2010, SFSP 04-2010 Revised: Eligibility Requirements for Military Families.
  • 2017–18 SBP and SFSP Start-up and Expansion Grants (added 04-Jan-2017)
    Management Bulletin SNP-01-2017/SFSP01-2017: CEC Section 49550.3: Availability of School Breakfast Program and Summer Food Service Program Start-up and Expansion Grants for State Fiscal Year 2017-18 Request for Applications.