Skip to main content
California Department of Education Logo

Request for Waiver of Provisions Support Letter 7

Support letter from Barbara Nemko requesting a waiver of provisions of sections of the Elementary and Secondary Education Act.

Accessible Alternative Version of the letter from Barbara Nemko, page 31-32 of the Waiver Support Letters (PDF).
This document provides text translation of the letter of support from Barbara Nemko regarding the Request for Waiver of Provisions letter.

Napa County Office of Education
2121 Imola Avenue
Napa, California 94559-3625
Telephone: 707-253-5600
FAX Number: 707-253-6841
Napa County Office of Education Web Site []

Barbara G. Nemko, Ph.D.

Business Services

Fiscal Services

General Services

Human Resources

Educational Services

Court & Community Schools

Curriculum & Instruction

Early Childhood Services

Regional Occupational Program

Safe Schools/Healthy Students


May 22, 2012

Michael Kirst, President
California State Board of Education
California Department of Education
1430 N Street
Sacramento, CA 95814

Dear Dr. Kirst,

This letter is to express our strongest possible support for California's "state defined" waiver request which will be before you on or after June 7, 2012.

We commend the Governor, State Board of Education and State Superintendent Tom Torlakson for strengthening California's request for a general waiver. It is essential that we are successful in our waiver request and are relieved from the current over-identification of schools and districts in program improvement. As school districts struggle during difficult financial times, we have an urgent need for greater spending flexibility to increase student achievement. Lastly, we need to transition to a single, transparent, state accountability system, as the current practice of reporting scores on dual accountability systems is confusing and incomprehensible to the general public.

Schools and districts in Napa County have continued to show impressive growth on our API scores. Yet, out of the many measures of AYP that we have met, one subgroup not meeting AYP has put schools into Program Improvement, undermining public confidence and teacher morale, instead of recognizing the growth and achievement that has been accomplished.

We believe evolving our current API system is best for California and its students. It is generally agreed that the focus on the more onerous status bar model of AYP has been an impediment to our moving forward to improve our API. California has been and will remain committed to continuous student achievement for all students and all subgroups.

We appreciate the timelines outlined in the waiver which demonstrate a strong commitment on the part of the State to consider revisions to the API (January 2013), determination of targeted schools and districts for improvement (March 2013) and identification of sanctions (interventions) based on the severity and persistence of underachievement problems (July 2013). We stand ready to assist our state and we assure you of our continued commitment to strong accountability measures on behalf of our students.

Thank you for supporting and strengthening the waiver request. It is time to move it forward so that we can continue to improve the education we provide to the children of California.


Barbara Nemko, Ph.D.
Napa County Superintendent of Schools

Patrick Sweeney, Ed.D., Superintendent
Napa Valley Unified School District

Bill McGuire, Superintendent [Note: Dr. Marylou Wilson is the district superintendent as of June 2016.]
St. Helena Unified School District

Esmeralda Mondragon, Ed.D., Superintendent
Calistoga Joint Unified School District

Tom Stubbs, Superintendent [Note: Dr. Cheryl Lynn de Werff is the district superintendent as of June 2016.]
Howell Mountain Elementary School District

Florence Eaton, Superintendent [Note: Ken Burkhart is the district superintendent as of June 2016.]
Pope Valley Union School District

Questions:   State Board of Education | 916-319-0827
Last Reviewed: Wednesday, July 6, 2016
Recently Posted in Editorials & Letters
  • LeadLearn2016 Professional Learning Conference (added 22-Jul-2016)
    Letter to County and District Superintendents, Charter School Administrators, and Principals regarding the LeadLearn2016 Professional Learning Conference.
  • History–Social Science Request for Reviewers (added 20-Jul-2016)
    Letter regarding the recruitment of individuals to participate in the evaluation of kindergarten through grade eight (K–8) instructional materials for the 2017 History–Social Science Adoption.
  • 2017 California History–Social Science (added 20-Jul-2016)
    Instructional Materials Adoption (Kindergarten through Grade Eight)
  • History–Social Science Recruitment (PDF) (added 20-Jul-2016)
    Recruitment flyer from The California Department of Education and State Board of Education. They are seeking reviewers to participate in the 2017 History–Social Science Instructional Materials Adoption.
  • Summer Meals Critical for California Children (added 18-Jul-2016)
    Letter to District and County Superintendents, Charter School Administrators, and School Principals regarding Summer Meals critical for California children.

  • Summer Meal Programs (added 18-Jul-2016)
    Letter from U.S. Secretary of Agriculture Thomas J. Vilsack and U.S. Secretary of Education John B. King, Jr. regarding U.S. Department of Agriculture’s Summer Meal Programs.
  • Staff Evaluation Reporting System Survey (added 18-Jul-2016)
    Letter to County and District Superintendents and Direct-Funded Charter School Administrators regarding the Staff Evaluation Reporting System Survey.
  • Professional Learning Modules for Instructors (added 13-Jul-2016)
    California Preschool Instructional Network region contacts for the Professional Learning Modules for Transitional Kindergarten Teachers and Administrators in California’s public schools.
  • Transitional Kindergarten Attachment (PDF) (added 13-Jul-2016)
    Professional learning modules for transitional kindergarten teachers and administrators in California’s public schools. List of Region contacts.
  • Career Technical Education Incentive Grant (added 29-Jun-2016)
    Letter to County and District Superintendents and Charter School Administrators regarding Career Technical Education Incentive Grant Request for New Applications.