Skip to main content
California Department of Education Logo

November 2018 IQC Draft Meeting Minutes

Instructional Quality Commission Draft Minutes of Meeting for approval.

Full Commission
Item 1.E.
January 25, 2019

DRAFT MINUTES OF MEETING: November 15–16, 2018

Instructional Quality Commission
An advisory body to the California State Board of Education
(Considered for approval on January 25, 2019)

Preliminary Report of Action

Thursday, November 15, 2018

Instructional Quality Commissioners Present:
  • Dean Reese, Commission Chair
  • Jocelyn Broemmelsiek
  • Christine Chapman
  • Shay Fairchild (arrived late)
  • Jose Flores
  • Risha Krishna
  • Jose Iniguez
  • Jose Lara
  • Yolanda Muñoz
  • Melanie Murphy-Corwin
  • Nicole Naditz
  • Julie Tonkovich
  • Jennifer Woo
Commissioners Absent:
  • Soomin Chao, Vice Chair
  • Lizette Diaz
  • Alma-Delia Renteria
  • Assemblywoman Sharon Quirk-Silva
Executive Director:
  • Stephanie Gregson
State Board of Education Liaison Present:
  • Patricia Rucker
  • Karen Valdes
  1. Full Instructional Quality Commission (Commission or IQC)
    1. Call to Order Commission
      Chair Reese called the meeting to order at approximately 10 a.m.

    2. Salute to the Flag
      Commissioner Krishna led the salute to the flag.

    3. Overview of Agenda
      There were no changes to the agenda.

    4. Approval of Minutes (Action)
      ACTION: Commissioner Lara moved to approve the September 19, 2018, Health Subject Matter Committee (SMC) meeting minutes and the September 20–21, 2018, Commission meeting minutes. Commissioner Muñoz seconded the motion. There was no discussion and no public comment. The motion was approved by a unanimous vote of the members present (12–0). Commissioner Fairchild was not present for the vote, and Commissioners Chao, Diaz, Renteria, and Assemblywoman Quirk-Silva were absent from the meeting.

    5. Report of the Chair
      Commission Chair Reese gave a report.

    6. Executive Director’s Report
      Executive Director Stephanie Gregson gave a report.

    7. Report for the State Board of Education
      State Board of Education (SBE) liaisons Rucker and Valdes gave reports.

    8. Other Matters/Public Comment: None

  2. World Languages Subject Matter Committee
    SMC Chair Naditz called the World Languages SMC meeting to order.

    1. 2019 World Languages Standards for California Public Schools, Kindergarten through Grade Twelve (WL Standards) (Information/Action)
      1. Discussion on Edits to the Draft WL Standards (Information)

      2. Public Comment on the Draft WL Standards
        Daly-Jordan Koch, California Teachers Association

      3. Committee Recommendation to the Full Commission the Approval of the Draft WL Standards (Action)
        ACTION: Commissioner Broemmelsiek moved to recommend to the full Commission the approval of the draft WL Standards, with the suggested edits on which the committee reached consensus. Commissioner Muñoz seconded the motion. There was no additional discussion and no public comment. The motion was approved by a unanimous vote of the committee members present (5–0). Commissioners Chao, Diaz, and Renteria were absent from the meeting.

    2. 2020 World Languages Framework for California Public Schools, Kindergarten Through Grade Twelve (WL Framework) (Information/Action)
      1. Report on the WL Focus Group Meetings and Public Comment Received Regarding the Revision of the WL Framework (Information)

      2. Draft Guidelines for the WL Curriculum Framework and Evaluation Criteria Committee (CFCC) (Information/Action)
        ACTION: Commissioner Tonkovich moved to recommend to the full Commission the CFCC guidelines for the update of the WL Framework with the changes recommended by the SMC. Commissioner Broemmelsiek seconded the motion. There was no additional discussion and no public comment. The motion was approved by a unanimous vote of the committee members present (5–0). Commissioners Chao, Diaz, and Renteria were absent from the meeting.

      3. Committee Recommendation to the Full Commission the Approval of WL CFCC Members (Information/Action)
        ACTION: Commissioner Tonkovich moved to recommend to the full Commission applicants numbered 603, 605, 606, 608, 610, 613, 615, 621, 622, 623, 625, 629, 636, 638, 640, 641, 649, 650, 655, and 656 for appointment to the WL CFCC. Commissioner Broemmelsiek seconded the motion. There was no additional discussion and no public comment. The motion was approved by a unanimous vote of the committee members present (5–0). Commissioners Chao, Diaz, and Renteria were absent from the meeting.

        ACTION: Commissioner Munoz moved to recommend to the full Commission applicants numbered 623 and 625 to serve as co-chairs to the WL CFCC. Commissioner Broemmelsiek seconded the motion. There was no additional discussion and no public comment. The motion was approved by a unanimous vote of the committee members present (5–0). Commissioners Chao, Diaz, and Renteria were absent from the meeting.

    3. Other Matters/Public Comment: None

  3. Visual and Performing Arts (VAPA) Subject Matter Committee
    SMC Chair Tonkovich called the VAPA SMC meeting to order.

    1. 2019 Visual & Performing Arts Standards for California Public Schools, Prekindergarten through Grade Twelve (Arts Standards) (Information/Action)
      1. Discussion on Edits to the Draft Arts Standards (Information)

      2. Public Comment on the Draft Arts Standards
        Tamara Carr, California Teachers Association

      3. Committee Recommendation to the Full Commission the Approval of the Draft Arts Standards (Action)
        ACTION: Commissioner Woo moved to recommend to the full Commission the approval of the draft Arts Standards, with the suggested edits on which the committee reached consensus. Commissioner Murphy-Corwin seconded the motion. There was no additional discussion and no public comment. The motion was approved by a unanimous vote of the committee members present (6–0). Commissioners Chao and Diaz were absent from the meeting.

    2. 2020 Visual and Performing Arts Framework for California Public Schools, Kindergarten Through Grade Twelve (Arts Framework) (Information/Action)
      1. Report on the VAPA Focus Group Meetings and Public Comment Received Regarding the Revision of the Arts Framework (Information)

      2. Draft Guidelines for the VAPA CFCC (Information/Action)
        ACTION: Commissioner Murphy-Corwin moved to recommend to the full Commission the CFCC guidelines for the update of the Arts Framework. Commissioner Naditz seconded the motion. There was no additional discussion and no public comment. The motion was approved by a unanimous vote of the committee members present (6–0). Commissioners Chao and Diaz were absent from the meeting.

      3. Committee Recommendation to the Full Commission the Approval of VAPA CFCC Members (Information/Action)
        ACTION: Commissioner Murphy-Corwin moved to recommend to the full Commission applicants numbered 804, 810, 812, 814, 818, 821, 823, 824, 828, 830, 834, 839, 840, 842, 843, 845, 849, 852, 856, and 869 for appointment to the VAPA CFCC. Commissioner Naditz seconded the motion. There was no additional discussion and no public comment. The motion was approved by a unanimous vote of the committee members present (6–0). Commissioners Chao and Diaz were absent from the meeting.

        ACTION: Commissioner Woo moved to recommend to the full Commission applicants numbered 818 and 828 to serve as co-chairs to the VAPA CFCC. Commissioner Murphy-Corwin seconded the motion. There was no additional discussion and no public comment. The motion was approved by a unanimous vote of the committee members present (6–0). Commissioners Chao and Diaz were absent from the meeting.

    3. Other Matters/Public Comment: None

  4. History–Social Science Subject Matter Committee (HSS SMC)
    SMC Chair Krishna called the History–Social Science SMC meeting to order.

    1. 2020 Ethnic Studies Model Curriculum (Information/Action)
      1. Committee Recommendation to the Full Commission Approval of the Ethnic Studies Model Curriculum Advisory Committee (MCAC) Members (Information/Action)
        ACTION: Commissioner Flores moved to recommend to full Commission applicants numbered 411, 415, 424, 427, 430, 431, 434, 435, 437, 444, 456, 473, 474, 479, 500, 521, 522, 529, 531, and 536 for appointment to the Ethnic Studies MCAC. Commissioner Lara seconded the motion. There was no additional discussion and no public comment. The motion was approved by a unanimous vote of the committee members present (6–0).

        ACTION: Commissioner Lara moved to recommend to the full Commission applicants numbered 431 and 531 to serve as co-chairs to the Ethnic Studies MCAC. Commissioner Muñoz seconded the motion. There was no additional discussion and no public comment. The motion was approved by a unanimous vote of the committee members present (6–0).

    2. Other Matters/Public Comment: None

***ADJOURNMENT FOR THE DAY***


Preliminary Report of Action
Friday, November 16, 2018

Instructional Quality Commissioners Present:
  • Dean Reese, Commission Chair
  • Jocelyn Broemmelsiek
  • Christine Chapman
  • Shay Fairchild
  • Jose Flores
  • Risha Krishna
  • Jose Lara
  • Yolanda Muñoz
  • Melanie Murphy-Corwin
  • Nicole Naditz
  • Julie Tonkovich
  • Jennifer Woo
Commissioners Absent:
  • Soomin Chao, Vice Chair
  • Lizette Diaz
  • Jose Iniguez
  • Alma-Delia Renteria
  • Assemblywoman Sharon Quirk-Silva
Executive Director:
  • Stephanie Gregson
State Board of Education Liaison Present:
  • Patricia Rucker
  • Ilene Straus
  1. Full Commission Reconvenes
    1. Presentation on the California School Dashboard
      Analysis, Measurement and Accountability Reporting Division Jenny Singh, Administrator, Academic and Accountability Unit gave a presentation on the California School Dashboard.

    2. Reports/Action from Subcommittees to the Full Commission

      WL SMC
      1. Approve and Recommend to the SBE the Draft WL Standards (Action)
        ACTION: WL SMC Chair Naditz moved to recommend to the SBE the approval of the draft WL Standards with the edits on which the committee reached consensus. Commissioner Muñoz seconded the motion. There was no discussion and no public comment. The motion was approved by a unanimous vote of the members present (12–0). Commissioners Chao, Diaz, Iniguez, Renteria, and Assemblywoman Quirk-Silva were absent from the meeting.

        ACTION: WL SMC Chair Naditz moved to delegate the WL SMC Chair and Vice Chair to work with the standards writer and CDE staff as they make the changes approved by the Commission. Commissioner Tonkovich seconded the motion. There was no discussion and no public comment. The motion was approved by a unanimous vote of the members present (12–0). Commissioners Chao, Diaz, Iniguez, Renteria, and Assemblywoman Quirk-Silva were absent from the meeting.

      2. Approve and Recommend to the SBE the Draft Guidelines for the WL CFCC (Action)
        ACTION: WL SMC Chair Naditz moved to recommend to the SBE the guidelines for the WL CFCC. Commissioner Broemmelsiek seconded the motion. There was no discussion and no public comment. The motion was approved by a unanimous vote of the members present (12–0). Commissioners Chao, Diaz, Iniguez, Renteria, and Assemblywoman Quirk-Silva were absent from the meeting.

      3. Approve and Recommend to the SBE the WL CFCC Members (Action)
        ACTION: WL SMC Chair moved to recommend to the SBE applicants numbered 603, 605, 606, 608, 610, 613, 615, 621, 622, 623, 625, 629, 636, 638, 640, 641, 649, 650, 655, and 656 for appointment to the WL CFCC.

        ACTION
        : WL SMC Chair Naditz moved to recommend to the SBE applicants numbered 623 and 625 to serve as co-chairs to the WL CFCC. Commissioner Tonkovich seconded the motion. There was no discussion and no public comment. The motion was approved by a unanimous vote of the members present (12–0). Commissioners Chao, Diaz, Iniguez, Renteria, and Assemblywoman Quirk-Silva were absent from the meeting.

      VAPA SMC
      1. Approve and Recommend to the SBE the Draft Arts Standards (Action)
        ACTION: VAPA SMC Chair Tonkovich moved to recommend to the SBE the approval of the draft Arts Standards with the edits the committee reached consensus. Commissioner Murphy-Corwin seconded the motion. There was no discussion and no public comment. The motion was approved by a unanimous vote of the members present (12–0). Commissioners Chao, Diaz, Iniguez, Renteria, and Assemblywoman Quirk-Silva were absent from the meeting.

        ACTION: VAPA SMC Chair Tonkovich moved to delegate the VAPA SMC Chair and Vice Chair to work with the standards writers and CDE staff as they make the changes approved by the Commission. Commissioner Murphy-Corwin seconded the motion. There was no discussion and no public comment. The motion was approved by a unanimous vote of the members present (12–0). Commissioners Chao, Diaz, Iniguez, Renteria, and Assemblywoman Quirk-Silva were absent from the meeting.

      2. Approve and Recommend to the SBE the Draft Guidelines for the VAPA CFCC (Action)
        ACTION: VAPA SMC Chair Tonkovich moved to recommend to the SBE the guidelines for the VAPA CFCC. Commissioner Murphy-Corwin seconded the motion. There was no discussion and no public comment. The motion was approved by a unanimous vote of the members present (12–0). Commissioners Chao, Diaz, Iniguez, Renteria, and Assemblywoman Quirk-Silva were absent from the meeting.

      3. Approve and Recommend to the SBE the VAPA CFCC Members (Action)
        ACTION: VAPA SMC Chair Tonkovich moved to recommend to SBE applicants numbered 804, 810, 812, 814, 818, 821, 823, 824, 828, 830, 834, 839, 840, 842, 843, 845, 849, 852, 856, and 869 for appointment to the VAPA CFCC. Commissioner Murphy-Corwin seconded the motion. There was no discussion and no public comment. The motion was approved by a unanimous vote of the members present (12–0). Commissioners Chao, Diaz, Iniguez, Renteria, and Assemblywoman Quirk-Silva were absent from the meeting.

        ACTION: VAPA SMC Chair Tonkovich moved to recommend to the SBE applicants numbered 818 and 828 to serve as co-chairs to the VAPA CFCC. Commissioner Murphy-Corwin seconded the motion. There was no discussion and no public comment. The motion was approved by a unanimous vote of the members present (12–0). Commissioners Chao, Diaz, Iniguez, Renteria, and Assemblywoman Quirk-Silva were absent from the meeting.

        HSS SMC
      4. Approve and Recommend to the SBE the Ethnic Studies MCAC Members (Action)
        ACTION: HSS SMC Chair Krishna moved to recommend to the SBE applicants numbered 411, 415, 424, 427, 430, 431, 434, 435, 437, 444, 456, 473, 474, 479, 500, 521, 522, 529, 531, and 536 for appointment to the Ethnic Studies MCAC. Commissioner Muñoz seconded the motion. There was a discussion and the motion was revised.

        ACTION: HSS SMC Chair Krishna moved to recommend to the SBE applicants numbered 411, 415, 424, 427, 430, 431, 434, 435, 437, 444, 473, 474, 478, 479, 500, 513, 521, 522, 531, and 536 for appointment to the Ethnic Studies MCAC. Commissioner Naditz seconded the motion. There was no additional discussion and no public comment. The motion was approved by a unanimous vote of the members present (12–0). Commissioners Chao, Diaz, Iniguez, Renteria, and Assemblywoman Quirk-Silva were absent from the meeting.

        ACTION: HSS SMC Chair Krishna moved to recommend to the SBE applicants numbered 431 and 531 to serve as co-chairs to the Ethnic Studies MCAC. Commissioner Muñoz seconded the motion. There was no discussion and no public comment. The motion was approved by a unanimous vote of the members present (12–0). Commissioners Chao, Diaz, Iniguez, Renteria, and Assemblywoman Quirk-Silva were absent from the meeting.

    3. Plan January 24, 2019, New Commissioner Orientation (Discussion)

    4. Individual Commissioner Reports

    5. Other Matters/ Public Comment: None

Chair Reese adjourned the meeting at approximately 10:30 a.m.


Questions:   Curriculum Frameworks and Instructional Resources Division | CFIRD@cde.ca.gov | 916-319-0881
Last Reviewed: Friday, January 11, 2019
Recently Posted in Commissions & Committees