Skip to main content
California Department of Education Logo

Meeting Minutes September 10, 2012

State of California
Edmund G. Brown Jr., Governor

Instructional Quality Commission
An advisory body to the California State Board of Education

Final Meeting Minutes:
September 10, 2012 Teleconference

(Approved on September 25, 2012)


Report of Action

September 10, 2012

3:30 to 5:10 p.m.

English Language Arts/English Language Development (ELA/ELD) Subject Matter Committee (SMC) Chair Jo Ann Isken called the meeting to order.

  1. Welcome and Introductions (Information) Commissioners and CDE staff present at the eleven sites participating in the conference call identified themselves.

    The following Commissioners participated:
  • Jo Ann Isken and Cynthia Gunderson at Lennox School District
  • Bill Honig in Mill Valley
  • Angel Barrett at Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Jose Dorado at Osceola Street Elementary School
  • Marlene Galvan at Dinuba Unified School District
  • Michelle Herczog at Los Angeles County Office of Education
  • Kristyn Bennett at Grace S. Thille Elementary School
  • Angie Estonina at San Francisco Unified School District
  • Lori Freiermuth at Olympian High School
  • Carla Herrera at ABC Unified School District

The following CDE staff members were present at the CDE, Sacramento:

  • Tom Adams
  • Tracie Yee
  • Jim Long
  • Kristen Cruz Allen
  • Lillian Perez
  • Nancy Brownell

The following public members were present:

  • Nancy Brynelson, Center for the Advancement of Reading
  • Hallie Yopp Slowik, Center for the Advancement of Reading
  • Ileana Davalos, Los Angeles Unified
  • Katie McGrath, Los Angeles Unified
  • Karla Quiñones, John F. Kennedy Academy (Dinuba)
  • Magdalena Ruz Gonzalez, Los Angeles County Office of Education
  1. ELA/ELD Curriculum Framework and Evaluation Criteria Committee Member Selection and Recommendation Process (Information)
    Staff reviewed the handouts members received in preparation for appointment of members to the Curriculum Framework and Evaluation Criteria Committee (CFCC), including the individual application packets, summary sheet of all applicants, and a nomination worksheet. To help streamline the compilation and discussion of applicants, all ELA/ELD SMC and other Instructional Quality Commission (IQC) members were asked to submit their nomination worksheet to staff before September 18. The appointment process and list of applicants will be discussed and finalized at the September 24 meeting.

  2. Guidelines for the Revision of the 2014 ELA/ELD Framework (Information)
    Due to time constraints, not all sections of the draft Curriculum Framework and Evaluation Criteria Committee Guidelines for the 2014 Revision of the English Language Arts/English Language Development Framework (2014 ELA/ELD Framework) were discussed at the August 20 meeting. A revised draft with edits from the August meeting was included in the agenda for discussion. The final two sections, 8 and 9, were reviewed and revised with suggested edits. Members clarified some of the suggested changes. An updated version of the draft guidelines will be forwarded to all ELA/ELD SMC and IQC members for discussion and approval at the September 24–25 meeting. The final draft will be forwarded to the State Board of Directors for approval in November.
    No actions were taken by the SMC.

  3. Public Comment
    There were no public comments.  

Chair Isken adjourned the meeting.

Last Reviewed: Wednesday, December 28, 2016
Trending in Commissions & Committees
Recently Posted in Commissions & Committees
  • March 27, 2017 H-SS SMC Minutes (added 23-May-2017)
    FInal minutes of the March 27, 2017 History-Social Science Subject Matter Meeting.
  • April 24, 2017 H-SS Meeting Minutes (added 23-May-2017)
    History-Social Science Subjet Matter Committee Meeting Mintues of April 24, 2017.
  • CPAG Meeting Notice and Agenda, June 2017 (added 22-May-2017)
    California Practitioners Advisory Group (CPAG) Public meeting notice and agenda for its June 1, 2017 meeting.
  • April 2017 CPAG Item 03 Slides (PDF) (added 13-Apr-2017)
    Item 03 Presentation on California and the Every Student Succeeds Act for the California Practitioners Advisory Group April 2017 Meeting.
  • April 2017 Agenda Item 01 Slides (PDF) (added 12-Apr-2017)
    Item 01 presentation update on the rollout of the California School Dashboard, including, but not limited to: Next Steps for the Dashboard, and Using the Dashboard to Support the Local Control Accountability Plan (LCAP) Pr

  • Apil 2017 Agenda Item 02 Handout 1 (DOC) (added 12-Apr-2017)
    Combining ELA and Math Indicators for the Lowest 5 Percent.
  • April 2017 Agenda Item 02 Slides (PDF) (added 12-Apr-2017)
    Item 02 presentation on the feedback on options for the methodology to identify not less than the lowest-performing five percent of all schools receiving Title I, Part A funds in the state for comprehensive support And imp
  • April 2017 Agenda Item 04 Slides (PDF) (added 12-Apr-2017)
    Item 04 presentation update and feedback on the English Learner Progress Indicator Workgroup; and update on the School Conditions and Climate Work Group, the Ad Hoc Family Engagement Work Group, and the Statements of Model
  • April 2017 Memorandum CPAG Item 03 (DOC) (added 12-Apr-2017)
    Feedback Regarding the Local Control and Accountability Plan Addendum to Meet Local Educational Agency Planning Requirements of the Every Student Succeeds Act.
  • April 2017 Memorandum CPAG Item 04 (DOC) (added 12-Apr-2017)
    Update on the School Conditions and Climate Work Group, the Ad Hoc Family Engagement Work Group, and The Development of The Statements of Model Practices.